Public Documents LUCAS COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
J. BERNIE QUILTER, CLERK
700 ADAMS STREET
TOLEDO, OHIO
TIME:   1:41:44 PM
DATE:   9/21/2017
CASE: G -4801 -CI -201403405-000  
TITLE: CAPITAL CARE VS STATE OF OHIO  
JUDGE: MYRON C DUHART   STATUS:   CLOSED/TERM'D
FILING DATE: 8/4/2014 CASE TYPE:   CI   CIVIL  

MONETARY AMOUNT:   DOCKET/PAGE:    
ORIGINAL COURT:   TAX TYPE:    
PREVIOUS CASE NUMBER:   STATE OF OHIO NUMBER:    

Party   Counsel
PLTF/APPELLANT 1:
CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
1160 WEST SYLVANIA AVE
TOLEDO, OH  43612
JENNIFER L BRANCH
5136219100
1409 ENQUIRER BUILDING
617 VINE STREET
CINCINNATI, OH  45202
PLTF/APPELLANT 1:
TERRY J. LODGE
4192557552
316 N. MICHIGAN
STE 520
TOLEDO, OH  436241627
DEFT/APPELLEE 1:
STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
246 NORTH HIGH STREET
COLUMBUS, OH  43215
LYNDSAY ATKINS NASH
6153876149
OHIO ATTORNEY GENERAL
30 E BROAD STREET 26TH FLOOR
COLUMBUS, OH  43215

DATE SEQ EVENT
8/4/20142Title : PLD:NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/5/20141Title : SRV:NOTICE OF APPEAL MAILED
COPY OF NOTICE OF APPEAL SENT CERTIFIED TO:
CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
1160 WEST SYLVANIA AVE
TOLEDO OHIO 43612
7013 1710 0002 2536 0828
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
8/5/20142Title : ORD:REFER ADMIN JUDGE/REASSIGN
At the request of JUDGE RUTH ANN FRANKS and for good cause
shown, this case is referred to Administrative Judge STACY
L. COOK for reassignment, pursuant to Rule 5.02 (D) of the
Local Rules of the Lucas County Common Pleas Court,
General Trial Division.
Date: August 05, 2014
JUDGE RUTH ANN FRANKS
SEE ORDER.
PARTY : -
8/5/20144Title : EVT:ORDER FILE & JOURN EFF6/13
EJOURNALIZED 08/06/2014
PERTAINING TO: THIS CASE IS REFERRED TO THE ADMINISTRATIVE
JUDGE STACY L COOK FOR REASSIGNMENT
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-06 11:47:52 AM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/6/20141Title : EVT:ORDER FILE & JOURN EFF6/13
EJOURNALIZED 08/06/2014
PERTAINING TO: ORDER OF REASSIGNMENT
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-06 04:33:32 PM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/6/20142Title : JRE:ADMINISTRATIVE TRANSFER
CASE REASSIGNED TO JUDGE DUHART DOCKET.
PER COURT ORDER DATED 8/6/14
PARTY : -
8/6/20143Title : JRE:ADMINISTRATIVE TRANSFER
PARTY : -
8/6/20144Title : EVT:ORDER FILE & JOURN EFF6/13
EJOURNALIZED 08/07/2014
PERTAINING TO: ORDER OF REASSIGNMENT
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-07 11:08:43 AM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/6/20145Title : EVT:ORDER FILE & JOURN EFF6/13
EJOURNALIZED 08/07/2014
PERTAINING TO: CASE REASSIGNMENT REQUEST TO ANOTHER JUDGE
ON THE LUCAS COUNTY COMMON PLEAS COURT BENCH; CASE IS
REASSIGNED TO JUDGE DUHART
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-07 11:08:43 AM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/6/20146Title : PLD:NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
OF COUNSEL
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
8/6/20147Title : MTN:MOTION FILED
APPELLANTS EMERGENCY MOTION TO SUSPEND AND STAY THE ORDER OF
THE OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH FROM WHICH APPELLANT APPEALS
AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/8/20141Title : PLD:PLEADING FILED
MEMO CONTRA OF THE OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH TO
APPELLANTS MOTION FOR STAY OF THE ORDER OF THE
OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/8/20142Title : PLD:AFFIDAVIT
AFFIDAVIT OF TERRIE HUBBARD IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO
SUSPEND AND STAY THE ORDER OF THE OHIO DEPARTMENT OF
HEALTH
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/11/20141Title : EVT:OPIN & JE FILED & JOURN
EJOURNALIZED 08/11/2014
PERTAINING TO: OPINION AND JOURNAL ENTRY
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-11 04:25:34 PM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-11 04:25:34 PM
JENNIFER L BRANCH
JBRANCH@GBFIRM.COM
Sent via email to DE-1's attorney on 2014-08-11 04:25:34 PM
LYNDSAY ATKINS NASH
lyndsay.nash@ohioattorneygeneral.gov
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/11/20142Title : ORD:OPINION ISSUED SEE JE
JOURNAL ENTRY
The Court hereby ORDERS that "Emergency Motion To Suspend
and Stay The Order of the Ohio Department of Health,"
filed by the appellant is granted. The Court further
ORDERS that this matter is assigned for a hearing to be
conducted on September 4, 2014, at 10:00 a.m. The Court
further ORDERS that the Court will establish a briefing
schedule upon notification by the parties, on or before
Friday, August 15, 2014, as to their choice of whether to
have this matter heard in an oral hearing on September 4
or, instead, in a non-oral hearing.
Judge Myron C. Duhart
PARTY : -
8/13/20141Title : EVT:J.E. FILED & JOURNALIZED
EJOURNALIZED 08/14/2014
PERTAINING TO: PETITION FOR PERMISSION TO PUBLICIZE COURT
PROCEEDINGS
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-14 04:30:03 PM
JENNIFER L BRANCH
JBRANCH@GBFIRM.COM
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-14 04:30:03 PM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
Sent via email to DE-1's attorney on 2014-08-14 04:30:03 PM
LYNDSAY ATKINS NASH
lyndsay.nash@ohioattorneygeneral.gov
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/15/20141Title : MTN:REQUEST FOR
APPELLEES REQUEST FOR NON-ORAL HEARING
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/15/20142Title : PLD:PLEADING FILED
CERTIFICATION OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE RECORD
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
8/21/20142Title : ORD:BRIEFING SCHEDULE
AGREED PROPOSED BRIEFING SCHEDULED:
ODH FILES RECORD WITH THE COURT: AUGUST 15, 2014
PARTIES AGREE TO ADDITIONAL STIPULATIONS REGARDING QUESTIONS
RAISED BY THE COURT: AUGUST 29, 2014
APPELLANT'S OPENING BRIEF DUE: SEPTEMBER 23, 2014
APPELLEE'S RESPONSIVE BRIEF DUE: OCTOBER 23, 2014
APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEF DUE: NOVEMBER 13, 2014
ORAL ARGUMENTS: TO BE SCHEDULED, IF NEEDED
JUDGE MYRON C. DUHART
PARTY : -
8/21/20143Title : EVT:J.E. FILED & JOURNALIZED
EJOURNALIZED 08/25/2014
PERTAINING TO: AGREED PROPOSED BRIEFING SCHEDULE
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-25 04:37:10 PM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2014-08-25 04:37:10 PM
JENNIFER L BRANCH
JBRANCH@GBFIRM.COM
Sent via email to DE-1's attorney on 2014-08-25 04:37:10 PM
LYNDSAY ATKINS NASH
lyndsay.nash@ohioattorneygeneral.gov
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
8/29/20141Title : RTN:CERTIFIED MAIL-NO SERVICE
RETURN RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL #7013 1710 0002 2536 0828
RECEIVED & ENDORSED BY POST OFFICE UNCLAIMED
ATTORNEY NOTIFIED 8/29/14
CAPITAL CARE NETWORK (NOTICE OF APPEAL)
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
9/22/20141Title : MTN:FOR LEAVE FILED
CAPITAL CARES MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE BRIEF IN
EXCESS OF PAGE LIMITATION
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
9/23/20141Title : PLD:BRIEF
APPELLANT CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDOS APPEAL BRIEF
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
10/1/20141Title : PLD:NOTICE OF FILING
PLAINTIFF-APPELLANTS NOTICE OF FILING OF AFFIDAVIT OF TERRIE
HUBBARD
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
10/1/20142Title : PLD:AFFIDAVIT
OF TERRIE HUBBARD
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
10/23/20141Title : PLD:BRIEF
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
11/13/20141Title : PLD:REPLY BRIEF
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
6/18/20151Title : PLD:NOTICE
NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
6/19/20151Title : ORD:OPINION ISSUED SEE JE
JUDGMENT ENTRY
The Court hereby ORDERS the appellant's request for
additional evidence is denied. The Court further ORDERS
that the July 29, 2014 "Adjudication Order" decision of
the interim Director, "refusing to renew and revoking [the
Appellant's] health care facility license," is not in
accordance with law. The Court further ORDERS that the
decision contained in that Adjudication Order is reversed.
The Court finds no just reason for delay.
Judge Myron C. Duhart
PARTY : -
6/19/20152Title : CLS:OPINION AND J.E.
PARTY : -
6/19/20154Title : EVT:OPIN & JE FILED & JOURN
E-JOURNALIZED 06/19/2015
PERTAINING TO OPINION AND ORDER
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2015-06-19 02:59:11 PM
TERRY J. LODGE
lodgelaw@yahoo.com
Sent via email to PA-1's attorney on 2015-06-19 02:59:11 PM
JENNIFER L BRANCH
JBRANCH@GBFIRM.COM
Sent via email to DE-1's attorney on 2015-06-19 02:59:11 PM
LYNDSAY ATKINS NASH
lyndsay.nash@ohioattorneygeneral.gov
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
7/10/20151Title : SRV:COPIES MAILED
COPY OF NOTICE OF APPEAL DOCKETING STATEMENT AND
PRACIPE MAILED ORDINARY MAIL
JENNIFER L BRANCH
1409 ENQUIRER BUILDING
617 VINE ST
CINCINNATI OH 45202
TERRY LODGE
316 N MICHIGAN STE 520
TOLEDO OHIO 43624 1627
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
7/10/20153Title : PLD:NOTICE OF APPEAL FILED
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
7/10/20154Title : PLD:DOCKETING STATEMENT
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
7/10/20155Title : PLD:PRAECIPE FILED
PARTY : DE1 - STATE OF OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
7/21/20151Title : EVT:ORIG FILE IN APPEALS FILE
COURT OF APPEALS NUMBER: L15-1186
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
7/27/20151Title : RTN:ORDINARY MAIL-NO SERVICE
RETURN ON ORDINARY MAIL NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED
JENNIFER L BRANCH
(COPY OF NOTICE OF APPEAL, PRAECIPE AND DOCKETING STATEMENT
PARTY : -
9/17/20151Title : EVT:COST BILL MAILED
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO
7/29/20161Title : MIS:MANDATE FILED
PARTY : PA1 - CAPITAL CARE NETWORK OF TOLEDO

Disclaimer : The public record information available here reflects the docket entries and journals required by Ohio law to be kept by the Lucas County Clerk of the Court of Common Pleas. This information reflects the actual documents filed and kept at the Clerk of Courts Legal Division, located in the Lucas County Courthouse, at Adams and Erie Streets in Toledo, Ohio, 43624. The data entry, though generally deemed reliable, cannot be guaranteed. The information may appear on the Internet Docket before the entry is actually signed and journalized. Of course the proposed action is official only when signed and journalized. In no event shall the Lucas County Clerk of the Court of Common Pleas, or any other Lucas County department, agency, or official be held liable for damage of any nature, direct or indirect, arising from the use of this Internet product; including loss of profits, loss of savings, or other incidental or consequential damages.